
This page explains; it does not advise
We are a directory, not a public adjuster, an insurance agent or a lawyer. What follows is a general explanation of how these processes usually work, so that a conversation with your carrier or your contractor is less one-sided. Your policy is the document that governs your claim, and the people qualified to interpret it are your carrier, a licensed public adjuster, or an attorney.
Four authorities, and they do not agree
| Authority | What it governs |
|---|---|
| Building department | whether a reroof needs a permit, how many layers may remain, underlayment and ice-barrier requirements, the decking inspection, and the final |
| State or local wind provisions | fastening patterns, edge metal, and in coastal jurisdictions whether components need product approval |
| Your insurance policy | what is covered, at what value, with what deductible — and whether code upgrades are paid for |
| HOA or deed restrictions | colour and material, enforceable against you regardless of the permit or the claim |
A carrier's estimate is not a code document, and a code requirement your carrier did not include is still a code requirement.
The code items a compliant reroof includes
- Layer limit. Most jurisdictions allow a limited number of roof coverings before a full tear-off is required — commonly two, and one in parts of the hurricane coast. Adding a layer over two is not a cheaper roof, it is a non-compliant one.
- Ice barrier at the eaves, required in cold climates. It exists because melt water backs up behind ice at the eave and finds its way under the covering, and it is the single most skipped code item in a price-driven bid.
- Underlayment type and coverage, and in high-wind jurisdictions a secondary water barrier on the deck.
- Fastening pattern, which is what actually determines wind performance — more than the shingle's own rating.
- Drip edge, valley metal and step flashing. Flashing at walls and chimneys causes more "the new roof leaks" calls than the field of the roof ever does.
Why the decking inspection matters
Where a jurisdiction inspects after tear-off and before the new covering goes on, an independent person sees the deck. That is the only stage at which rot, delamination, inadequate fastening or the wrong sheathing thickness can be found and documented.
It is also the stage where the money moves. Decking replacement is the most common addition to a roofing invoice, which is why the unit rate belongs in the contract and the photographs belong on your phone.
A plain explanation of a storm claim
| Term | What it means in practice |
|---|---|
| Actual cash value (ACV) | replacement cost minus depreciation — usually the first payment |
| Replacement cost value (RCV) | the full cost to replace; the difference from ACV is usually released after the work is completed and invoiced |
| Deductible | your share of the loss. It is not negotiable by a contractor, and offers to absorb it are a legal problem rather than a discount |
| Code upgrade / ordinance and law coverage | pays for code items a modern reroof requires that the old roof did not have — an ice barrier, a secondary water barrier — and it is a coverage you either have or do not |
| Supplement | a request to the carrier for additional scope found during the work, supported by photographs |
| Assignment of benefits | signing your claim rights over to the contractor. Sometimes appropriate, never something to sign in a driveway |
Two practical notes. Document before mitigation where it is safe to do so, because the photographs are the claim. And the carrier's estimate is a settlement position, not a specification — the roof still has to comply with the code whatever the estimate says.
Who pulls the permit
Have the contractor pull it, and write that into the contract along with who meets the inspector. When a homeowner pulls the permit for work someone else performs, the homeowner takes on the code-compliance exposure.
An unpermitted reroof is a standard resale finding. It is also the reason a warranty conversation can collapse: a manufacturer's warranty is generally conditional on installation to their instructions, and there is nothing to demonstrate that with once the covering is on and no inspection happened.
Sources behind this guide
This guide explains general practice, and rests on the references below. Each link goes to the organisation’s own front page rather than to a deep page that might move. A model code is not your local rule: your jurisdiction adopts a particular edition and amends it, and the licensing regulator for each state is linked from that state’s page on this site, and is the authority for anything about who may do the work.
- International Code Council: the International Residential Code, Chapter 9 (Roof Assemblies), including its provisions on roof coverings, reroofing and, in cold climates, the ice barrier at the eaves. Your jurisdiction adopts a specific edition and amends it, so the building department’s version is the one that binds.
- National Roofing Contractors Association: the trade association whose roofing manual is the usual reference for flashing, underlayment and fastening details.
- National Association of Insurance Commissioners and your state’s department of insurance: how claims, actual cash value and replacement cost value are generally handled, and where complaints about claim conduct go.
- Federal Trade Commission: 16 C.F.R. Part 465, the Rule on Consumer Reviews and Testimonials, which is why this site publishes no reviews.
No named individual reviewed this guide, and it is not legal, engineering or insurance advice. Where a city page on this site shows a local figure, it was read from that jurisdiction’s own rules and linked; where it does not, the page says so and names the office to call.