
The sentence that should end the conversation
"We'll take care of your deductible." Or waive it, absorb it, or build it into the invoice.
In a large number of states this is insurance fraud, explicitly legislated against, and the exposure is not only the contractor's: a homeowner who knowingly signs an inflated invoice is part of it. It is also a reliable signal about everything else in the bid, because a contractor willing to misstate a price to a carrier is telling you how they handle paperwork generally.
The deductible is the homeowner's share of the loss. A contractor who makes it disappear has either inflated the claim or is absorbing a cost they will recover somewhere you will not see. Neither is a discount.
Run this on every bid, including ours
- Get the licence or registration number and look it up yourself. Confirm it is held by the entity that will sign your contract. Where the state licenses roofing as its own classification, check the classification too.
- Ask how long the business has been at its current address. In this trade that is the most useful question nobody asks, because the workmanship warranty is worth what the company is worth in year three.
- Have the certificate of insurance sent to you by the insurer, naming you as certificate holder — general liability and workers' compensation both. Roofing has among the highest injury rates in construction, and an uninsured fall on your property can become your problem.
- Ask who pulls the permit and whether the decking is inspected after tear-off. That inspection is the one moment someone independent sees your deck.
- Get a unit rate for decking replacement in writing, per sheet, before anyone starts. "We'll let you know what we find" is an open cheque on the one cost that is genuinely unpredictable.
- Get the assembly specified by name: underlayment type, ice barrier where required, starter and ridge components, valley treatment, drip edge, pipe boots, and the nailing pattern the manufacturer specifies for your wind zone.
- Read the contract for an assignment of benefits clause. Signing over your claim rights to a contractor changes who negotiates with your carrier and, in some states, who may sue whom. It is sometimes appropriate and never something to sign in a driveway.
- Read the payment schedule. In a claim, the first cheque is usually the actual-cash-value payment; the rest comes after completion. A contractor asking for the full replacement cost up front has not explained how the claim works.
What a storm-chaser contract looks like
Not all visiting contractors are bad, and plenty of local ones behave worse. But the pattern below repeats, and recognising it is worth more than a general warning.
- A "contingency agreement" presented as an inspection authorisation. Read it: some bind you to use that contractor for whatever the carrier approves.
- An assignment of benefits buried in the same page.
- Pressure tied to the claim deadline rather than to the weather. Carriers have deadlines; they are rarely as short as the pressure implies.
- A price that exactly matches the carrier's estimate regardless of scope — which tells you the estimate is being treated as the budget rather than the specification.
- No local address, or an address that is a mailbox. Ask where the office is and when they opened it.
Photograph the deck
After tear-off and before the underlayment goes on, photograph the whole deck, plus close-ups of any rot, delamination or gaps, with something of known size in frame and the date recorded.
This is the only evidence that will ever exist about what was under your roof, and decking charges are the most common source of a disputed final invoice. A roofer who knows the deck is being photographed prices the deck honestly.
What a good roofer will refuse to do
- Discount, absorb or "take care of" the deductible.
- Roof over a second layer where the code allows only one, or over wet or rotten decking.
- Skip the ice barrier where the code requires it to match a cheaper bid.
- Promise a claim outcome. They do not work for the carrier and cannot know what it will pay.
Where to complain if it goes wrong
The registry or board that licensed them is the first stop. For claim conduct — inflated invoices, deductible waiving, unlicensed adjusting — your state department of insurance handles it, and it takes those complaints seriously. The building department has enforcement over unpermitted work.
If the contractor came to you through this site, tell us as well. We cannot arbitrate your dispute and will not pretend to. What we can do is stop listing them.